The warranty you can't price is the risk you're already carrying
When reviewing an investment term sheet, ask who would bear a loss if an important assurance later proves wrong. The answer depends on the eventual sale agreement, its disclosures and any warranty and indemnity insurance. Insurance Business UK's October report on the International Underwriting Association's Transactional Liability Committee paper describes transactions in which insurance carries much of the buyer's recovery risk. That makes the relationship between those documents worth examining early.
Those questions can be raised while the commercial terms are still being negotiated.
Compare the legal exposures alongside the valuation
Consider an investor comparing potential acquisitions. The financial models look workable, yet the decision remains difficult because the documents allocate risk in different ways. One proposal offers contractual recourse against a seller. Another relies more heavily on insurance. A third leaves a material qualification unresolved. Comparing the headline prices alone will not explain those differences.
A decision becomes easier to assess when the uncertain term and its financial consequence are stated explicitly.
Read the promise alongside the route to recovery
The report discusses lower policy retentions, transactions without a seller indemnity and increased claims notifications. Its no-seller-indemnity figures concern North American transactions placed by Marsh, so they should not be treated as a measure of the UK market. The English judgment in Veranova Bidco LP v Johnson Matthey Plc [2026] EWHC 1021 (Comm) separately illustrates why contractual limitations on warranty claims matter. The court examined whether the buyer could satisfy the fraud requirement needed to overcome the agreed limitations.
The practical question for a particular deal is what the buyer could recover, from whom, and on what conditions. A reference to insurance in a term sheet leaves those questions to be answered in the policy and transaction documents.
Why this makes an investor freeze
If the term sheet in front of you says "no seller indemnity, W&I to cover warranty breaches", the real economic question is what sits behind each warranty and what a claim would actually recover. That has three moving parts: the warranty wording, the policy that sits over it, and the disclosure letter that carves out everything the seller has told you about. Read those documents together and identify which terms remain open. A clear question for the seller or insurer is more useful than an unresolved concern in the investment paper.
The resulting issues should be recorded alongside the financial model so that the investment committee can assess them.
The move that unfreezes the decision
Name the unknown, then price it. In practice that means three concrete steps on any live term sheet.
- Mark every warranty you cannot price. Only the ones where you cannot say what a breach would be worth.
- Push each one into one of three buckets: covered by the policy on readable terms, carved out by disclosure, or live risk that needs a specific indemnity, a price chip or a walk-away.
- Decide the deal on what is left after that sort, rather than on the glossy summary at the front of the pack.
This is not exotic work. It is what a transactional team does on an ordinary Tuesday. It changes the decision because it converts a vague fear into a line you can accept, reject or negotiate. That gives the team a concrete basis for the next negotiation.
A note on timing
A delay leaves the commercial question unresolved. Before committing to a timetable, identify the points that need an answer, the documents needed to answer them and the person responsible for each. Check which provisions of the term sheet are intended to bind the parties and when any agreed deadlines expire. The effect depends on the wording and applicable law.
If you have a term sheet or a warranty pack in front of you and something about it will not let you sign, that something has a name. Message me on LinkedIn to pressure-test one term sheet, or call FjM on +44 7968 394381. A focused review can help identify the questions to resolve before the next commitment.
Source: Insurance Business UK, "Why the W&I insurance market is closer to the edge than the data suggests" (20 October 2026), reporting the IUA Transactional Liability Committee W&I paper.
The Veranova judgment is available from The National Archives.